Update — Jana Riess: There are more young lesbian, gay or bisexual Latter-day Saints than previously believed – Salt Lake Tribune
Update, June 25, 2021 • After we published this article June 21, Brigham Young University professor Justin Dyer emailed Jana with some questions about the rates of LGB+ identifiers among Latter-day Saint respondents in the Nationscape survey. In a nutshell, Nationscape weighted its data to make the sample representative of voters in the United States, but not necessarily of Mormons, which means we should interpret it carefully.
In particular, there is a geographical disparity in the data. The roughly 35% of Latter-day Saint respondents who were not from the western United States had particularly high rates of sexual diversity, with Gen Z Mormons outside the West at 64% heterosexual, compared to the West at 88%. The numbers from the Northeast diverged the most, though the number of Latter-day Saint respondents there was very small.
It would not be surprising for Latter-day Saint respondents outside of the Mountain region to be less conservative than those in Mormon-heavy areas. That’s something we’ve seen on multiple surveys. There is also evidence from multiple surveys (Pew Religious Landscape, Cooperative Election Study and Next Mormons Survey) that self-identified Latter-day Saints outside the West are less religiously active, on average, than those in the West.
Thus, it is not unreasonable to expect that Nationscape’s data is correct in its overall finding that non-Western Mormons report higher levels of sexual diversity than those in the West, since those things often correlate together. (By way of comparison, the Cooperate Congressional Study shows Latter-day Saints under age 35 outside of the West at 17% LGB+ and those in the West at 10%, although again, these are small sample sizes.) However, the difference is a large one, over 20 points, so we think it’s good to exercise caution with the specific percentages that Nationscape reported.
Given that a) Latter-day Saints outside the West are less politically conservative and religiously active, on average, than those in the West, that b) other large-scale surveys show similar patterns of young Latter-day Saints identifying as LGB+ at higher rates than older Latter-day Saints, and that c) Latter-day Saints outside the West are only a third of the overall Nationscape sample of Mormons, we suspect that the overall trend lines from the Nationscape data are on the right track (i.e., younger Latter-day Saints are showing higher levels of sexual diversity than previous generations, and those differences are more pronounced in non-Mormon areas).
That said, it is unlikely that the rates of sexual diversity are as high as indicated below for Gen Z and millennial Latter-day Saints. Our estimate is that they may be around 7 to 9 percentage points lower than indicated in the Nationscape data reported.
We appreciate those who reached out with this information. This is how science (ideally!) should work — multiple experts review the same evidence and through repeated analyses we (hopefully!) get closer to the truth of what we are studying. It is also important to keep in mind that the averages of multiple surveys tend to be more accurate than any one study standing alone.
For this column, we’re leaving the original column largely as is and adding this addendum because we want to be transparent about what the original conclusion was and what we learned next, and thus how we adjusted our expectations. The opening statement and a subordinate headline, however, have been changed to remove Nationscape’s one-fifth figure that is now in dispute.
We will be paying close attention to future studies about sexual orientation and generational change as they become available.
— Jana Riess and Benjamin Knoll
A growing number of Generation Z Latter-day Saints do not self-identify as heterosexual, according to a major national study.
The Nationscape dataset, which canvassed more than 318,000 Americans on a rolling basis in 2019 and 2020, had 3,881 self-identified members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in the survey. This makes it one of the largest studies of Mormons ever fielded in the United States.
One of the most valuable aspects of the data is what it can tell us about the basic demographics of this population, including gender, race, geography and sexual orientation.
Not surprisingly, there is more sexual diversity among younger Latter-day Saints than older ones. While 94% of baby boomers said they were heterosexual, just 77% [see update above] of Generation Z did. (This analysis borrows Pew’s cutoff dates for the generations, which uses 1997 as the first birth year of Gen Z. Only adult Gen Zers over age 18 were eligible for the study.)
So, 23% of Gen Zers who identify as LDS say they are lesbian, gay, bisexual or other [see update above]. And nearly as many (19%) of millennials did as well. It’s notable that this finding is nearly double the 10% that Benjamin Knoll and I found among millennials in the 2016 Next Mormons Survey (which broke down into 7% bisexual, 2% gay or lesbian, and 1% “other”).
Let’s unpack the Nationscape study’s finding of 23% a bit more. Within Gen Z, the major outliers compared to other generations of Latter-day Saints were the categories of bisexual and “other.”
We think three points are worth making here.
First, generationally, sexual diversity is high among Gen Z Mormons because it’s high among Gen Z as a whole. In terms of sexual orientation, Nationscape’s Gen Z Latter-day Saints look a lot like non-Mormons their same age.
So Gen Z Latter-day Saints, like their counterparts around the nation, are more likely to identify as queer. According to Pew’s recent study of Gen Z, they seem more comfortable with gender fluidity and same-sex marriage than any other generation, though millennials come close.
Gen Zers are also more likely to feel fine stating their sexual orientation on a survey. Fewer than 1% chose the “prefer not to say” option in the Nationscape study, compared to 2% to 4% of the members of older generations who did not want to answer the question. The atmosphere today for stating a nonheterosexual identity is far more hospitable than it was even a decade ago, and many Gen Zers don’t personally remember a time when they could be fired from a job for being LGBTQ.
The second point is that Gen Z Mormons currently show more sexual diversity than older generations of Latter-day Saints because, frankly, some of them are statistically likely to leave the church but have not yet done so.
The Gen Z respondents in the Nationscape study were 18 to 22 at the time of the survey. According to our own research in The Next Mormons, the median age for leaving the church is around 19. In other words, there is still some settling and sorting yet to happen here. We are by no means saying that all of these queer-identifying young adult Mormons are going to exit the church, of course — only that statistically, more will likely do so than their heterosexual peers.
It’s not surprising that it’s harder for queer members to stay. The church has made a point for years of fighting same-sex marriage, condemning nontraditional families as “counterfeit,” and preventing church members who are in a same-sex relationship from attending the temple, holding certain callings or exercising the priesthood. While there have beenimportant steps toward compassion and understanding in the past few years, that damage still runs deep.
So the percentage of queer Gen Z Latter-day Saints will probably not be as high as 23% in future studies. That won’t be because these people will have magically become heterosexual as they get older. It will be because they will have ceased to be Mormon, and will drop out of the pool of respondents who currently identify as members. As well, some heterosexuals will likely continue to switch in to the religion through conversion, possibly enough to change the ratio going forward.
Finally, one surprising aspect of the study is related to race and geography. Nationscape’s data suggests that among Mormons, some racial and ethnic minorities were more likely to also be sexual minorities.
Among all Americans, heterosexuality was 87% for Hispanics and 90% for Blacks, but among Latter-day Saints it was 71% for Hispanics and 74% for Blacks. It’s a statistically significant difference because the sample size is big enough that this isn’t just a random sampling error. Still, it’s unclear why Black and Hispanic Mormons exhibit more sexual diversity than their non-LDS counterparts.
Incidentally, the Nationscape study showed a double-digit difference between Mormons who lived in Utah (94% heterosexual) and those who did not (83% heterosexual). This echoes and widens a smaller 4-point difference we found in the 2016 NMS regarding the sexual orientation of Mormons in Utah versus Mormons elsewhere.
We speculate that this is the result of self-selection, in that red-state Utah may just be a more challenging place for sexual minorities to live, at least outside of Salt Lake City.
Note • This includes data analysis by Benjamin Knoll.