One of the great sports movies skipped over the truth. This TV show gets it right – Sydney Morning Herald
A League of Their Own ★★★★
At first blush it seems A League of Their Own is a mere retread of the 1992 film of the same name, widely and rightly regarded as one of the all-time great sports movies. But for all its virtues, Penny Marshall’s comedic take on the real-life tale of the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League that ran from 1943 to 1954 left something pretty major out of the picture – and this eight-parter sets the record straight, so to speak.
Like the film, this League focuses on one team, the Rockford Peaches. Unlike the film, it is very much a queer history. In some ways, it owes as much to the Ryan Murphy-produced documentary A Secret Love (2020) as it does to Marshall’s movie.
Peachy keen: Shirley (Kate Berlant), Carson (Abbi Jacobson), Terri (Rae Gray), Greta (D’Arcy Carden) and Jo (Melanie Field).Credit:Anne Marie Fox/Prime
As one character remarks: “I bet 35 per cent of the league are queers.” But aside from Rosie O’Donnell’s ambiguous presence, Marshall’s movie skirted that fact entirely. (As a mark of just how much the dial has moved, O’Donnell – who did not come out until 2002 – crops up in a delightful cameo here as Vi, the butch owner of a secret gay bar.)
With Broad City’s Abbi Jacobson as lead and co-creator, this League puts sexuality, gender and race front and centre. It plays for laughs, but it has serious business on its mind too – namely, the isolation, fear and potentially disastrous repercussions that came with being gay in 1940s America, and the way the league served as a safe(ish) space for gay women to find themselves, a community and, in some cases, partners, albeit in secret.
Jacobson plays Carson Shaw, a married woman from small-town Idaho who runs away to join the four-team women’s league launched by candy manufacturer Morris Baker (Kevin Dunn) – a fictionalised version of Philip K. Wrigley – in a bid to keep his Chicago stadium busy while so many male players are away at war.
It’s a time of massive upheaval, when factories are forced first to drop their no women rule, then their no blacks rule and finally their no black women rule.
For Max Chapman (Chante Adams), the story’s second key character, that means a chance to play for the factory baseball team, just so long as she can convince the sexist coach to give her a trial. Oh, and to persuade her mother that there’s nothing wrong with her for wanting to play ball in the first place.