Gay Identity vs. Jewish Practice – WSJ – The Wall Street Journal

I recognize the difficulties and complexity of Yeshiva University’s situation (“AOC Tries to Bully Yeshiva University” by Tal Fortgang, op-ed, Oct. 3), and I don’t presume to know what should be done. I am sure, however, that Mr. Fortgang’s analogy has an issue: Student clubs for Shabbat violators and bacon eaters would be about what people do. An LGBT club is about who people are.

Sanford Goldstein